Organic Vs. Paid Search And Social Media: A Guide For Local Business Owners

Last updated on

Local business owners frequently encounter a common dilemma in digital marketing.

With a plethora of choices expanding almost daily, compounded by the integration of AI, determining the optimal and most efficient approach for your business can be challenging.

At the outset, local businesses typically weigh two (or technically four) main avenues: organic and paid strategies across search engines and social media platforms.

This guide will delve into the intricacies of each avenue, evaluate their advantages and disadvantages, and provide practical advice to aid in making well-informed decisions about where to allocate your valuable time, resources, and budget.

Understanding Organic And Paid Strategies

Let’s begin by outlining the fundamental distinction between organic and paid strategies:

Organic: This approach centers on cultivating long-term brand awareness, trust, and authority through consistent creation and distribution of high-quality, optimized content and active community engagement. It focuses on nurturing a loyal customer base, which naturally demands dedicated time and effort.

Paid: This strategy involves investing in online advertising campaigns to gain immediate visibility and reach a broader audience swiftly. While it offers a shortcut to visibility, it necessitates careful management to balance costs against lead volume and quality.

For local business owners navigating both search and social media platforms, the choice between organic and paid strategies involves weighing considerations of time, resources, and initial implementation costs against anticipated results.

In the following sections, we’ll delve into essential best practices for achieving success, along with a comprehensive look at the advantages and disadvantages of each strategy.

While not explicitly highlighted as a best practice, it’s crucial to understand that ongoing monitoring and optimization are essential for adapting strategies based on desired outcomes and performance—a critical component of effective digital marketing efforts.

Search Engine Marketing (SEM)

The term “search engine marketing” is often mistakenly associated exclusively with paid strategies. However, it should actually be recognized as the umbrella term encompassing both organic search (local SEO) and paid search (PPC).

Organic Local SEO

The objective of local SEO is to ensure that your business prominently appears in the Local Map Pack and/or organic search results when potential customers search for the services or products you offer.

Local SEO shares similarities with traditional SEO but involves additional steps to optimize effectively.

Best Practices:

  • Keyword research: Identify keywords related to your business’s services/products, location, and competitive landscape, which potential customers are likely to search for.
  • Website/on-page optimization: Develop a mobile-friendly, responsive website with a local focus. Optimize title tags, headings, internal/external links, meta descriptions, and content using relevant keywords.
  • Local listings: Maintain a comprehensive and active Google Business Profile (GBP), ensuring consistent NAP (Name, Address, Phone Number) across all online directories.
  • Reviews: Encourage positive, genuine customer reviews, particularly on your Google Business Profile, and promptly respond to feedback to enhance local credibility.
  • Backlinks: Cultivate inbound links from relevant local and industry-specific sources to bolster your website’s authority.
  • Content marketing: Regularly create and share high-quality, locally relevant content that addresses your audience’s queries and consistently delivers value.


  • Cost-effective: While SEO demands time and effort for research, identifying opportunities, implementing best practices, and monitoring results, the overall cost (depending on various factors) tends to be lower compared to paid search campaigns.
  • Credibility: Organic search results are generally perceived as more trustworthy by users.
  • Long-term benefits: A well-optimized online presence (including an optimized website, Google Business Profile, high-quality content sharing, and relevant backlinks) can consistently attract organic traffic over an extended period.


  • Delayed results: Building authority and trust through SEO is a gradual process. It may take several months to see significant outcomes from SEO efforts.
  • Algorithmic and AI dependence: Search engine algorithms and the role of AI, such as large language models (LLMs) influencing search results, are continually evolving. This necessitates ongoing optimization to stay relevant.
  • Competitive: Gaining authority and visibility for popular keywords can be challenging, particularly for local businesses in densely populated areas.

Some argue that establishing local authority and visibility is closely tied to running a reputable business, providing excellent services, and actively engaging with the community.

Well-managed local businesses that effectively engage in local SEO have the opportunity to be discovered by their customers through organic search results.

Local Paid Search (PPC)

Paid search encompasses the creation and distribution of compelling text, image, or video ads (including YouTube) on Google or Bing’s search and display networks. These ads are linked to conversion-oriented standalone pages or website landing pages.

On a local scale, service-oriented businesses can opt for Google Local Services Ads, which involve a verification process for qualified businesses.

Best Practices:

  • Keyword selection: Opt for relevant keywords with high search volumes and low competition.
  • Ad copy refinement: Craft compelling ad copy that emphasizes your unique value proposition.
  • Landing page optimization: Design landing pages that align seamlessly with your ad copy and encourage conversions.
  • Remarketing: Target users who have previously engaged with your website by displaying ads tailored to their interests and behaviors.


  • Immediate visibility: Ads linked to specific keyword searches appear prominently at the top of search results instantaneously.
  • Targeted outreach: Ads can be finely targeted to specific demographics and geographic locations.
  • Measurable outcomes: Track impressions, clicks, and conversions to evaluate campaign effectiveness and adjust ad expenditures accordingly.


  • Expensive: PPC advertising can incur high costs, especially for competitive keywords like “plumbers in New York.” According to a Wordstream study, the average click-through rate (CTR) on Google Ads is 1.91% on the search network and 0.35% on the display network. This means you may need to pay for numerous impressions to generate clicks.
  • Quantity over quality: High PPC traffic volumes do not necessarily equate to increased conversions.
  • Click fraud: Clicks may originate from bots or competitors, resulting in a portion of your budget being wasted.
  • Temporary results: Once you cease paying for PPC campaigns, your ads and subsequent traffic will disappear.

Social Media Marketing (SMM)

Social media is ubiquitous in our modern world, impacting businesses of all sizes. Yet, many local businesses remain uncertain about its role in their marketing strategies.

The key lies in understanding your business’s nature and your audience’s preferences. Can you produce content suitable for platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, or TikTok? Will your audience actively seek out this content on these channels?

For most local businesses, embracing social media offers a valuable opportunity to extend their community presence online.

Organic Social Media

Organic social media involves sharing text, images, audio, video, and/or links across various social media platforms.

To ensure this content reaches and resonates with your audience, it’s crucial to cultivate a social following—a step often overlooked in social media marketing.

Best Practices:

  • Visual Appeal: Use high-quality images and videos to captivate your audience.
  • Content Calendar: Plan and schedule your social media posts ahead of time.
  • Hashtags: Employ relevant, keyword-rich hashtags to expand your reach and attract users searching for related content.
  • Calls to Action: Prompt viewers to click, visit, or make a purchase.
  • Audience Engagement: Follow, like, and share content from other local businesses and creators in your niche.
  • Community Interaction: Respond promptly to comments, messages, and mentions to foster engagement.


  • Cost-effective: Most social media platforms are free to use.
  • Brand building: Strengthen customer relationships, build a community, and showcase your brand’s personality.
  • Customer engagement: Directly interact with customers, answer their questions, and address their concerns.


  • Limited reach: Even with a dedicated following, organic reach on social media is decreasing, making it harder to reach a large audience.
  • Social network dependency: Algorithms on social media platforms determine the visibility of content, limiting potential reach.
  • Time-consuming: Creating engaging content and managing multiple social media accounts requires a significant time investment.

Paid Social Media

Paid social media advertising, similar to paid search, allows for text, image, or video ads to be distributed on social networks where your audience is most engaged.

Best Practices

  • Audience Targeting: Create and target hyper-local custom audiences based on demographics, interests, and behaviors tracked by social networks.
  • Ad Format: Select the appropriate ad format for your campaign objectives, such as image ads, video ads, or carousel ads.
  • Ad Copy: Write compelling ad copy that highlights your unique value proposition.
  • Landing Page Optimization: Design landing pages that align with your ad copy and encourage conversions.


  • Targeted Reach: Ability to reach very specific demographics, interests, and behaviors.
  • Increased Visibility: Opportunity to boost popular organic posts to reach a larger audience.
  • Measurable Results: Ability to track clicks, impressions, and conversions for analyzing and optimizing campaign performance.


  • Costly: Paid social media advertising can be expensive, especially in competitive industries or densely populated locations.
  • Ad Fatigue: Consumers may become annoyed or indifferent to excessive or intrusive advertising.
  • Algorithm Dependency: Social media algorithms prioritize paid content, making it challenging for organic posts to gain traction.

Local Challenges

Regardless of the chosen tactic, local business owners need to acknowledge and address several challenges.

  • Limited Budgets: Local businesses often have smaller marketing budgets, making it difficult to compete with larger companies on paid search and social media platforms. Be strategic in your spending, focusing on targeting the right audience with the right message.
  • Local Competition: Local businesses face stiff competition from others in their area, both online and offline. Standing out can be challenging, especially in saturated markets. Differentiate your business through unique value propositions, exceptional customer service, and targeted campaigns.
  • Limited Resources: Many local businesses have limited staff and digital marketing expertise, making it hard to manage complex paid search and social media campaigns effectively. Consider outsourcing to a digital marketing agency or consultant, but research their track record and results with other local businesses.
  • Keeping Up with Trends: Staying current with the latest trends and best practices can be overwhelming for local businesses. Partnering with a digital marketing expert can help them stay ahead of the curve.

Choosing The Right Strategy For Your Local Business

The most effective approach for your local business will depend on your specific goals, budget, and target audience. When assessing your options, consider the following factors:

  • Goals: What are you aiming to achieve? Is it increasing brand awareness, driving traffic to your website, generating leads, or boosting sales?
  • Budget: How much are you willing to spend on marketing? Determine your budget on a monthly, quarterly, or seasonal basis.
  • Target Audience: Who are you trying to reach? Identify the keywords your audience might use when searching for your services or products, and determine which social media platforms they frequent.
  • Timeframe: How quickly do you need to see results for a particular service or product offering?

A well-rounded digital marketing strategy often involves a combination of organic and paid tactics. It’s not about choosing organic vs. paid, but rather integrating both for optimal results.

A common and effective approach is to identify organic keywords or topics where your business already has some level of authority and visibility, from which you are receiving traffic and can build upon.

This might involve a unique product or service you offer, or something particularly popular with your customers. Focus your local SEO efforts on these areas.

Simultaneously, identify high-value, low-competition keywords worth paying for through PPC or paid social ads, ensuring they deliver quick and meaningful results.

Another strategy is to use paid search or social ads as a testing ground. This helps you understand which keywords or topics resonate with your audience and on which channels before committing to a comprehensive organic content strategy.

If your budget allows for a comprehensive approach, integrate both paid search and paid social into your digital marketing strategy. Use paid search to capture high-intent users actively searching for your products or services, and paid social to build brand awareness, nurture leads, and reach a broader audience.

A Few Words On Analytics

Digital marketing has risen in prominence not just due to growing consumer expectations for instant results, but also because of the profound influence of data on every online interaction.

Despite being occasionally overwhelming, digital marketing allows for meticulous tracking, analysis, and optimization of strategies based on real-time performance insights.

For instance, website interactions and inbound traffic can be monitored using tools like Google Analytics. PPC advertisements provide comprehensive data on impressions, clicks, and conversions through platforms such as Google Adwords and Bing Ads. Moreover, nearly all paid social media platforms offer detailed tracking features.

For small businesses, it could be as straightforward as knowing the number of leads or paying customers coming from online channels.

Yet, the more precise data you gather about the specific channels bringing customers to your online store or physical location, the more insightful it becomes.

The ultimate goal is to accurately gauge the return on investment from each channel. Even approaching this goal helps affirm the validity of your strategic choices.

The Decisions Are Yours

Ultimately, determining which strategies best suit your specific needs will be your decision and will undoubtedly necessitate refinement over time.

By grasping the actual expenses, advantages, and disadvantages of each method, you can craft a well-rounded approach that yields measurable outcomes.

Original news from SearchEngineJournal